Sober ’90s pop star awarded $70,000 after being wrongfully arrested for DUI
A ’90s pop star is getting a major payday after she was wrongfully arrested for driving under the influence.
Stefanie Fair, a former member of the teen girl group Wild Orchid, was arrested by the Tennessee Highway Patrol while driving in Nashville, Tennessee, in June 2024. According to a December 2024 report from WSMV 4, which has been probing into a handful of wrongful DUI arrests in the state, Trooper Keith Velez stopped Stefanie, 53, for failing to pull over, claiming he could smell alcohol on her breath during a field sobriety test.

“There’s a very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle,” Velez told Stefanie, according to bodycam footage obtained by the outlet.
“When he started asking me about drinking, I instantly got this feeling in my stomach — this is bad,” Stefanie, meanwhile, recalled in her conversation with WSMV 4. “When he said he could smell it, I knew it was corrupt. This is completely wrong.”
According to the video footage obtained by the outlet, Stefanie was seen at a Chill-N ice cream store in Brentwood, Tennessee, just one hour before the arrest.
Two months later, however, Stefanie’s bloodwork came back completely clean, confirming she was in fact sober while driving, WSMV 4 reported.
Her husband, Ron Fair, believes Stefanie was “extorted’ for her famous reputation after her name and mugshot were used “inaccurately,” with both Ron and the musician’s attorney, Benjamin K. Raybin, telling WSMV 4 that the couple paid a $7,500 fee for her mugshot to be removed from Scoop Nashville, a local social media gossip site.
The incident ultimately resulted in Stefanie suing Tennessee Highway Patrol Trooper Velez, with WSMV 4 reporting on Tuesday, November 17, that she was awarded a $70,000 settlement. According to the outlet, a spokesperson for the Tennessee attorney general said the settlement was approved by the State Board of Claims, with a payout expected in the next few weeks.
“I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them,” Raybin told the outlet.
According to WSMV 4’s investigation, titled “Sobering Problem,” Stefanie is the second sober driver to file a federal lawsuit against Tennessee troopers, who, per the report, have made up to nine wrongful DUI arrests against sober drivers in recent years.

