The couple first said “I do” on June 24 in Old Bridge, New Jersey

NEED TO KNOW

Jenni “JWoww” Farley and Zack Carpinello said “I do” again!

The Jersey Shore legend, 41, and the professional wrestler, 31, exchanged vows for a second time in a romantic ceremony overlooking Lake Como in Italy on Monday, July 20, during their multi-stop European honeymoon, PEOPLE exclusively reveals. The couple first tied the knot in a surprise, Beauty and the Beast-inspired wedding at Madison Modern Social in Old Bridge, New Jersey, on Wednesday, June 24.

“We wanted our New Jersey celebration at Madison’s to be an opportunity for our loved ones who weren’t able to travel to Italy to celebrate with us,” the newlyweds tell PEOPLE. “We gathered with our close friends and family in New Jersey, while our celebration in Italy was a more intimate experience for us.”

The intimate dinner celebration was attended by “a few very close longtime friends.”

“For me, it was really about having an intimate, meaningful moment with Zack,” Farley says. “His family is from Italy, so celebrating there felt special to us. We wanted a celebration that felt uniquely ours, and we did exactly that.”

Farley wore a stunning, sleeveless gown with a pop of red by Castle Couture, the same designer behind her first floral wedding dress. Meanwhile, Carpinello opted for the black suit by Carmen Bucco of Bucco Couture that he wore when he first married Farley. He also incorporated red with his vibrant tie and matching pocket square.

Farley and Carpinello’s first wedding in New Jersey was attended by 50 guests, who gathered for what they thought was a special screening of the reality TV star’s film, Nanny Cam.

They told PEOPLE ahead of their wedding that watching everyone’s reactions to the big reveal was the moment they were most excited for, sharing, “We’ve spent months keeping this secret, creating invitations, planning the movie-themed details, and building the surprise. Seeing our family and friends go from thinking they’re attending a special screening for Nanny Cam to realizing they’re actually at our wedding will be a moment we’ll never forget.”

Among the guests were Farley and ex-husband Roger Mathews‘ kids — 12-year-old daughter Meilani and 10-year-old son Greyson — as well as Jersey Shore stars Nicole “Snooki” Polizzi, Sammi “Sweetheart” Giancola with husband Justin May, Mike “The Situation” Sorrentino with wife Lauren Sorrentino, and Deena Cortese Buckner with husband Chris Buckner.

“We wanted the day to feel personal, memorable, and full of joy, and there’s something really special about sharing such a meaningful surprise with the people we love most,” Farley and Carpinello told PEOPLE at the time.

Although Farley and Carpinello grew up just one town apart, they didn’t start dating until years later. They got engaged on top of the Empire State Building in New York City on Farley’s 36th birthday in 2021.

In June, the pair told PEOPLE that they look forward to “more family adventures, continued growth together, and creating a lifetime of memories with our children, family, and friends.”