Charlotte officials demand Iryna Zarutska’s wrongful death lawsuit is dismissed

Officials from the City of Charlotte, North Carolina, are asking a judge to entirely dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, who was fatally stabbed aboard a tram in August 2025.

Footage showing the alleged killer, DeCarlos Brown Jr, stabbing Zarutska in the neck, leaving her bleeding and begging those on the busy train for help before she died, shocked the nation last year.

Zarutska’s uncle filed the lawsuit against the City of Charlotte and its transit security company Professional Security Services (PSS) for alleged ‘systemic failures’ a year after the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee was brutally murdered.

But a mediation meeting between the uncle and the defendants’ attorneys earlier this month did not bring any advancements in the case, The Charlotte Observer reported.

Instead, on Monday, the city for the first time publicly spoke out on the uncle’s allegations, filing a motion to dismiss in the Mecklenburg County Superior Court.

In the motion cited by the Observer, the attorneys stated: ‘The City recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by DeCarlos Brown Jr’ and added that it simultaneously denies that it ‘ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack.’

In his lawsuit, Zarutska’s uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, claimed his niece’s death could have been prevented. He alleged the city’s failure to ‘protect lawful passengers from known and foreseeable dangers’ caused the tragedy.

In his filing, Haskell further claimed that the city’s insufficient fare enforcement, without turnstiles at any stop, enabled Brown, a homeless man who previously told police he had schizophrenia, to launch the attack on Zarutska.

The suit also alleged that PSS was not properly staffed on the night Zarutska was killed.

The City of Charlotte provided funding for 219 security personnel for fiscal years 2025 and 2026 but allegedly had only 183 staff members when the young woman was killed, according to the filing.

The lawsuit added that, under the budget, 39 guards were supposed to be armed but claimed that only 11 were on staff at the time.

The city was also accused in the lawsuit of instructing light rail conductors not to confront passengers who do not pay fares. The filing additionally cited four other homicides and assaults that occurred near Blue Line stops in recent years.

The filing claimed that Zarutska’s alleged killer did not pay the light rail fare before boarding the tram.

Surveillance footage from the tragic night appeared to show the career criminal watching Zarutska for some time as she sat in the row directly in front of him before taking a blade from his pocket.

Brown then stood up and loomed over her, swinging the knife at her while she sat on her phone.

As he exited the train, Brown left behind a trail of blood, though other passengers did not appear to realize a murder had occurred in front of them.

Video then showed Zarutska curled up with her knees against her chest and her hands over her mouth as she looked up at her attacker.

About 15 seconds later, she fell to the floor.

The City contended that ‘systemwide crime and incidents’ made the violent attack ‘reasonably foreseeable,’ while also disputing that insufficient security staffing or a lack of fare enforcement caused the 23-year-old’s death.

Brown was arrested shortly after the stabbing and remains in custody.

Leave a comment